MSTY vs SHW: Dividend Comparison
Dividend data as of
Yieldmax MSTR Option Income Strategy ETF (MSTY) from N/A and Sherwin Williams Co (SHW) from Materials offer different dividend profiles for income-focused portfolios. MSTY offers a significantly higher 285.70% yield compared to SHW's 0.87%, a gap of 284.83%. For dividend growth, SHW leads with a 5-year CAGR of 9.5% versus MSTY's -72.8%. SHW is a Dividend Aristocrat with 40 years of consecutive increases.
Verdict
Yield Analysis
MSTY yields 284.83% more than SHW. In dollar terms, MSTY pays $78.13/share vs SHW's $3.16/share annually.
Dividend Growth
MSTY: Dividend growth has been steady, with a 3-year CAGR of -72.8% and a 5-year CAGR of -72.8% (10-year: -72.8%).
SHW: Dividend growth is accelerating — the 3-year CAGR of 14.3% exceeds the 5-year rate of 9.5% and the 10-year rate of 12.2%.
Dividend Safety
SHW: The payout ratio of 31% is well within sustainable levels, leaving room for future increases. Earnings cover the dividend 3.3x.
Estimated Annual Dividend Income
Based on current dividend yields. Actual income may vary.
What does $10,000 buy in MSTY vs SHW today?
At $24.09 per share, $10,000 buys about 415.2 shares of Yieldmax MSTR Option Income Strategy ETF (MSTY). Each share pays $78.13 per year in dividends, so the position starts out generating roughly $32,438 per year — about $2,703 a month.
At $368.50 per share, $10,000 buys about 27.1 shares of Sherwin Williams Co (SHW). Each share pays $3.16 per year in dividends, so the position starts out generating roughly $86 per year — about $7 a month.
MSTY is the larger income stream from day one: $32,352 per year more on the same $10,000 invested.
What could $10,000 of MSTY or SHW income look like in 10 years?
Yieldmax MSTR Option Income Strategy ETF (MSTY)'s dividend has shrunk about 72.8% a year over the past five years. If that trend continued, today's $28,570 per year on $10,000 (at the current 285.70% yield) would fall to $0 per year by 2036.
Sherwin Williams Co (SHW) has raised its dividend about 9.5% a year over the past five years. If that pace held, the $87 per year that $10,000 generates today at the current 0.87% yield would reach $214 per year by 2036 — a 2.1% yield on the original cost.
On those trailing rates, SHW pays more in 2036: $214 versus $0 per year. The projection assumes each five-year growth rate persists and no dividends are reinvested — real payouts will differ.
When would SHW's dividend growth overtake MSTY's higher yield?
Sherwin Williams Co (SHW) yields less today (0.87% vs 285.70%) but has grown its dividend faster — 9.5% vs -72.8% a year over the past five years. If both trends continued, a $10,000 position in SHW would start out-earning the same position in MSTY around 2031 (roughly 5 years from now), paying about $136 per year at the crossover. Before that point, MSTY pays more each year; after it, the gap compounds in SHW's favor.
Why is there no payout ratio for MSTY?
REWD has neither an earnings-per-share figure nor a payout ratio for Yieldmax MSTR Option Income Strategy ETF (MSTY) — typical for ETFs and covered-call funds, whose distributions are funded by the underlying portfolio (stock dividends, option premium, or return of capital) rather than a single company's earnings. For a fund, judge sustainability by the distribution history and the strategy behind it, not a payout ratio.
Sherwin Williams Co (SHW) earns $10.28 per share against $3.16 paid out in dividends — 3.3x coverage (a 31% payout ratio). That's the usual corporate affordability test — it just doesn't translate to the fund side of this comparison.
Which fits an early-retirement income portfolio better, MSTY or SHW?
For income you need right now, Yieldmax MSTR Option Income Strategy ETF (MSTY) leads: $100,000 invested today pays about $23,808 a month at the current 285.70% yield, versus $72 a month from Sherwin Williams Co (SHW) at 0.87%.
With a decade or more before the income is needed, SHW's faster dividend growth (9.5% vs -72.8% a year) matters more than the starting yield — raises compound into the larger paycheck over time.
On consistency: SHW has raised its dividend 40 consecutive years.
Many income investors simply hold both — the mix pairs current yield with growth and spreads single-name risk. Whichever way you lean, dividends are never guaranteed; recheck the payout each quarter rather than setting and forgetting.
$10,000 with DRIP: projected annual income
If each holding keeps raising its dividend at its real 5-year rate and every payment is reinvested, a $10,000 position pays $45,636/yr in MSTY vs $234/yr in SHW by year 10.
Assumes dividends are reinvested at the current yield and grow at each holding's trailing 5-year dividend CAGR. A projection, not a prediction — no price appreciation modeled.
Track MSTY and SHW in your portfolio
See your real income from both — forward projections, yield on cost, and dividend safety signals. Sync your brokerage free for 30 days, or track holdings manually on the free plan.
Frequently Asked Questions
Related Resources
Individual Stock Analysis
Dividend Tools
Track Your Dividends
More Comparisons
This tool is for educational and informational purposes only and does not constitute investment, financial, tax, or legal advice. Consult a licensed professional before making investment decisions.
Past performance does not guarantee future results. All projections are hypothetical estimates based on user-provided inputs and may differ materially from actual outcomes.
By using this tool you agree to our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.